Civil War Scout
  • Home
  • About
  • Blog
  • Resources
    • Civil War FAQs >
      • What Caused the Civil War?
    • Primary Documents
  • Scouting Reports
    • Shiloh National Military Park
  • Intelligence Reports
    • Elementary Readers
    • Middle School Readers
    • Mature Readers
    • Scholars
  • Contact

Intelligence Report--Behind Rebel Lines: The Incredible Story of Emma Edmonds, Civil War Spy

3/30/2017

0 Comments

 
Picture
​Behind Rebel Lines:  The Incredible Story of Emma Edmonds, Civil War Spy
By Seymour Reit
Middle School Readers
3 stars
As an action hero, Sarah Emma Edmonds is the Lara Croft of the Civil War.  Assuming the identity of the male soldier Franklin “Frank” Thompson, she joined the Union Army in 1861 as a battlefield nurse, and spent time as a courier before taking on the role of Union spy.  If young women of your acquaintance need a historical role model, they could certainly do worse than Sarah Emma Edmonds.
Behind Rebel Lines has been on my reading list for longer than Civil War Scout has existed.  I have been anticipating this fictionalized version of Edmonds’ story, but in the end, it didn’t live up to my (perhaps too lofty) expectations.

At just under 150 pages, this is a relatively short book, and as such, it doesn’t provide more than a few pages of context to explain Edmonds’ adopting a male persona even before her time in the Union Army.  This results in a rather flat character who is driven by vague, unspecified motivations usually attributed to an “imp voice”.  Unfortunately, this motivation is confusing for several reasons: 
  • the “imp voice” does not drive Edmonds to act mischievously or with malice as would be expected in the definition of imp, but instead to take calculated risks;
  • it take the focus of her decision-making away from the logic she uses (which is demonstrated on several occasions in the story) and ascribes it instead to an uncontrollable force, which undermines Edmonds’ agency; and,
  • it implies a lack of maturity that does a disservice to the real life Edmonds.
​
This book was originally written in 1991 and has been republished several times.  The language and stereotypes may be a bit jarring, especially when Edmonds takes on the personas and dress of others as she is inserts herself in her spy career, but I suspect that much of that comes directly from her memoirs and is indicative of the contemporary accounts during the Civil War.
 
Though it is on my (extensive) reading list, I have yet to read Edmonds’ memoirs Nurse and Spy in the Union Army, so I can’t judge how faithfully the narrative follows the original memoirs, but I can confirm that the soldier Allen Hall, whom Edmonds discovered on one of her espionage missions, does show up on the muster rolls of the 25th Virginia Infantry which fought at Gaines Mill (also known as the First Battle of Cold Harbor), so it does lead credence to the veracity of the story.  Until I have a chance to read the source documentation (or what the author claims as his source documentation), I will categorize this as historical fiction.
​
A great companion to this book is the History Channel’s Full Metal Corset: Secret Soldiers of the Civil War which introduces Edmonds with more background and fleshes out her personality and her history.
0 Comments



Leave a Reply.

    Author

    Toni is a wife, mom and history buff who loves bringing the Civil War to life for family members of all ages.

    Archives

    July 2018
    June 2018
    May 2018
    January 2018
    October 2017
    July 2017
    June 2017
    May 2017
    March 2017
    February 2017
    January 2017
    December 2016
    September 2016
    August 2016
    June 2016
    May 2016
    April 2016

    Categories

    All
    Black History Month
    Book Review
    Bull Run
    Causes
    Chancellorsville
    Charleston
    Children
    Confederate
    Courage
    Death
    Ellwood
    Fort Sumter
    Franklin
    Fredericksburg
    General History
    Gettysburg
    Hunley
    Kids Book
    Letters
    Manassas
    Medicine
    Monuments
    Murfreesboro
    Music
    Navies
    New Market
    Shiloh
    Slavery
    Soldiers
    Spies
    States-rights65a8dce77a
    Stones-river
    Stonewall-jackson
    Technology
    Travel
    Union
    Wilderness
    Women's History Month

    RSS Feed

© COPYRIGHT 2015. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.
  • Home
  • About
  • Blog
  • Resources
    • Civil War FAQs >
      • What Caused the Civil War?
    • Primary Documents
  • Scouting Reports
    • Shiloh National Military Park
  • Intelligence Reports
    • Elementary Readers
    • Middle School Readers
    • Mature Readers
    • Scholars
  • Contact